Return to: Editorial Opinion News

Clinton's Fatal Lie: Sudan and the US Terrorism List



The Africa Research Centre has published Clinton’s Fatal Lie: Sudan and the US terrorism list, a 368-page critique of the United States government’s listing of Sudan as a state sponsor of terrorism.

Clinton’s Fatal Lie: Sudan and the US terrorism list can be read or downloaded at



Clinton’s Fatal Lie: Sudan and the US terrorism list is a detailed study of the Clinton administration’s listing of Sudan as a state sponsor of terrorism in 1993, and its continued listing as such, and concludes that Khartoum’s designation was politically-motivated and without foundation from the very beginning. This was also the conclusion of former President Jimmy Carter who publicly stated at the time that Sudan was listed “without proof”. Rather than being based on evidence Carter was told that there had been “strong allegations” – allegations subsequently seen have been false. Sudan’s listing also flies in the face of two decades of active cooperation with the US in counter-terrorism.

The study examines in detail every reason advanced for Sudan’s listing and finds them to have been unjustified. The book then traces how this political abuse of federal anti-terrorism legislation by an administration noted for deceit set into motion a chain of events which included rejecting repeated Sudanese offers of counter-terrorism cooperation and intelligence-sharing which would have seen the extradition of Osama bin Laden to the US in 1996 and the snuffing out of the al-Qaeda terrorist organisation before it metastasized. Simply put, the atrocities of 9/11 would have been prevented had President Clinton and his administration accepted the Sudanese offers rather than perpetuating a lie. In this respect the study also echoes the comments made by Michael Scheuer, the head of the special CIA section tracking bin Laden from 1996 to 1999, who believes that short-sighted and incompetent politicians such as Bill Clinton, his counterterrorism director Richard Clarke and national security advisor Sandy Berger were to be held accountable in part for 9/11: “Bill, Dick and Sandy helped to push Americans out of the windows of the World Trade Center on that September morning.” The book states that Sandy Berger’s subsequent prosecution and conviction in 2005 for stealing and destroying top-secret White House memos and papers in the National Archives was in all likelihood Berger erasing evidence of the Sudanese extradition offer.

Clinton’s Fatal Lie: Sudan and the US terrorism list examines the systemic US intelligence failure with regard to Sudan, including the withdrawal of over 150 CIA intelligence reports in the 1990s alleging Sudanese involvement in terrorist plots because they were subsequently revealed to have been false. The book also reviews the disastrously inept 1998 US missile strike on the al-Shifa pharmaceutical factory in Khartoum, an attack based on similarly false claims about Sudanese involvement with bin Laden and weapons of mass destruction in an eerie prequel to Washington’s invasion of Iraq on equally spurious grounds.

The study outlines for the first time the extent of US-Sudanese counter-terrorism and intelligence cooperation once the Clinton administration had left office, cooperation described by the Bush administration’s Deputy Secretary of State Richard Armitage as “really terrific”. Sudan has saved American lives and holds the line in a region wracked by terrorism and Islamist militancy. Despite two decades of counter-terrorism cooperation, however, Washington has broken repeated promises from senior US officials to remove Sudan from the state sponsors of terrorism list, a list it should never have been on in the first place. Washington has instead continued to use the terrorism list as a political tool and in so doing undermining the credibility of the war on terrorism. Clinton’s Fatal Lie: Sudan and the US terrorism list demonstrates that the Clinton administration lied, lied and then lied again with regards to Sudan and terrorism. The book concludes that the American people were let down by the political ineptitude, deceit and arrogance of the Clinton administration and its political appointees – many of whom were subsequently recycled in the Obama administration.

The author of the study, David Hoile, concludes

“The United States has cried wolf regarding Sudan and terrorism from 1993 onwards and knowingly continues to do in its continued listing of Sudan as a state sponsor of terrorism. Washington also cried wolf on weapons of mass destruction in Sudan. The reality is that Sudan has stood shoulder to shoulder with the United States in the war on terrorism. President Donald Trump was elected in large part on a promise to ‘drain the swamp’ in Washington and to challenge the ‘fake news’ that sustains it. It is in President Trump’s gift to reverse decades of the Washington establishment’s double standards and fake claims regarding Khartoum and reward an ally by removing Sudan from the state sponsors of terrorism list. ”


Notes for Editors

Clinton’s Fatal Lie: Sudan and the US terrorism list has nine chapters: The United States and Sudan; The US State Sponsors of Terrorism List; Sudan’s designation as a state sponsor of terrorism; Clinton’s refusal to take Osama bin Laden into custody; The Al-Shifa pharmaceutical factory fiasco; US-Sudanese counter-terrorism cooperation; The 2002 US terrorist plot that wasn’t; The systemic US intelligence failure regarding Sudan; and The USS Cole lawsuits: Opportunism versus facts, as well as nine appendices, a bibliography and 1,962 footnotes.

About the Author Dr David Hoile is an African scholar and public affairs consultant specialising in African affairs and defence and security analysis. He is the author of several books, including Justice Denied: The Reality of the International Criminal Court (2014 and updated 2017), The International Criminal Court: Europe’s Guantánamo Bay? (2010) and Darfur: The Road to Peace (2008). He has commented on public policy issues on CNN, BBC News 24, BBC World Service, BBC Focus on Africa, Al-Jazeera English and Arabic, Voice of America, Deutsche Welle, France 24, Radio France Internationale, Chinese Central TV, Press TV, Al-Arabiya and the South African Broadcasting Corporation.

The author can be contacted by email at africaresearchcentre@gmail. ...

News Release: Clinton's Fatal Lie: Sudan and the US Terrorism List
Submitted on: January 17, 2018 05:12:12 PM
Submitted by: Michael Sibanda
On behalf of: www.africaresearchcentre.eu/files/PressReleaseClintonsFatalLie.pdf
advertisement